First Nations Clean Water Act
Bill C-37 establishes a legal framework giving First Nations authority over water, drinking water, wastewater, and related infrastructure on their lands, allowing them to set their own water safety standards.
First Nations communities would gain the legal power to manage their own safe drinking water systems, helping to end the long-standing drinking water advisories that have affected many reserves.
The debate · 6 points
Supporters say
- The bill would give First Nations authority over drinking water and wastewater on their lands, affirming their inherent right to self-government.
- It would set enforceable national drinking water standards and regulations, closing gaps in current protections.
- It commits the federal government to predictable, long-term funding and to a First Nations-led water commission, building on $4.6 billion over five years and the lifting of 158 long-term water advisories since 2015.
Critics say
- The bill defines First Nations lands as reserve lands only, which may leave out traditional territories and raise doubts about whether UNDRIP, including Article 25, fully applies.
- Chiefs say they were not properly consulted on this version of the bill, and a treaty table agreed to with the Crown has not yet met.
- Critics say the bill is weaker than the previous version, Bill C-61, and that it lacks true co-development with First Nations, which many chiefs have requested.